You are not logged in. You can log in or create an account to save favorites and join collections. more info

Longevity Without Misery

00:00
00:00
Audio loading...
Serial: 
BZ-03106
AI Suggested Keywords: AI-generated, learn more
AI Summary: AI-generated, learn more

The talk interprets “longevity without misery” through aging, loss, interdependence, and the transmission of Dharma across generations. Drawing on women’s Zen stories, it emphasizes kinship with all life, compassionate presence amid suffering, women’s access to ordination and leadership, and the need for sanghas to address abuse through accountability and independent ethical structures.

Texts and works referenced
- The Hidden Lamp, edited by Florence Caplow and Susan Moon — Its stories and commentaries provide the talk’s central examples, including the Old Woman’s Relatives, Darlene Cohen, and Mahapajapati.
- The First Free Women: Poems of the Early Buddhist Nuns — The poem on Mahapajapati presents care for all children as a path and supports the talk’s emphasis on mentorship across generations.
- “Gate of Sweet Dew” and “Kain Ramon” — Chants performed at the Segaki ceremony; their dedication invokes “longevity without misery,” the talk’s guiding phrase.

AI Suggested Title: Aging Together With Compassion

Is This AI Summary Helpful?
Your rating helps us improve AI summaries.
Transcript:

All right. When unsurpassed, penetrating and perfect, It's such a pleasure and privilege today to have Tova Green with us.

[01:14]

Tova Green resides and practices at San Francisco Zen Center. She is a student of Adrian Linda Coates and received Dharma Transmission in 2015. She began her Zen practice at Berkeley Zen Center in 1990. after meeting Alan Sinaki and Sue Moon at a Buddhist Peace Fellowship Conference. Tova has lived at all three San Francisco Zen Center temples and has been a resident since 1999. She co-founded City Center's Queer Dharma Group and has been involved in San Francisco Zen Center's racial justice work for over 20 years. Tova is a licensed clinical social worker and while living at City Center, worked for Zen Hospice Project and Hospice by the Bay.

[02:21]

She reads and writes poetry and plays the cello. Thank you, Penelope, for inviting me to be part of this One Day Women's Sitting. and for all the organizing work you've done. And I also want to thank the other members of the Sangha who have supported Penelope in making this day possible. So I want to also thank Mary, who's my GCO for today. I hope you could hear what I said earlier. And Karen, the dawn. Hannah, who is the greeter. And if there's anyone I left out, please forgive me. Robin, I know it takes many people to organize an event like this.

[03:25]

And I'm so happy to be here. and to be with all of you, including those who are participating from your homes, your one sangha. So recently, it was Friday night at City Center, we had a sajiki ceremony. A sajiki is, in case any of you are not familiar with it, it's a ceremony that's an invitation to the hungry ghosts, to those beings, including parts of ourselves who are undernourished,

[04:28]

unsupported or feel unsupported. And the ceremony is often done in Japan in August. It's an obon ceremony. But we've, at least as long as I've been at Sun Center, we've celebrated it very close to Halloween. And at City Center, people dressed up in costumes and The whole building is decorated with scrolls depicting hungry ghosts and some of the other things that we hang like spiders and that you see all around for Halloween at this time of year. And it's kind of a liminal time of year. The leaves are falling and it's so close also to the Day of the Dead, Dia de los Muertos. So it's a time of year when many people feel the change, and change in season, change, days are getting shorter, nights longer.

[05:39]

And one thing that struck me in the chanting this year, we chant the Gate of Sweet Dew and the Kain Ramon. And there's a dedication at the end that the chant leader, the Kokyo, offers. May the living be blessed with longevity without misery. May the living be blessed with longevity without misery. And as a person who's older, 82, very soon. I think about that. Because as we grow older, and I think we're all growing older no matter what age you are, there's, for me, both an increasing sense of the preciousness of life, but also an awareness of loss.

[06:45]

How can we meet change and loss, sometimes loss of abilities, loss of loved ones? How can we see that, embrace that part of aging and learn from it? And I think when I hear the phrase, alterity without misery, misery, excuse me, it can have to do with a state of mind, as well as with the conditions under which we're living. And I know I feel very fortunate to be living in a safe place, to have housing, to have food, to be living in a community. people who practice, and we're all ages, which is something I appreciate about living in San Francisco Center.

[07:54]

But, you know, this is a very challenging time for all of us, everyone on the planet, I think, with the climate crisis, with so many wars, with hunger, refugees, and in our country, very unstable political situation. And I imagine some people who might have been here today are doing voter registration work. You know, it's really important. So what does this mean to be blessed with longevity? And what stories can help us? I think about what we can learn from our women ancestors as well as what we can learn from contemporary women teachers and what we can learn from each other. We all have our stories and strengths that help us get through these difficult times.

[08:56]

So in my talk today, I'm going to draw on some stories from The Hidden Lamp, which perhaps Many of you are familiar with this book. It was edited by Susan Moon, who was part of this sangha, was one of the people who drew me to Zen practice, and Florence Kaplow. I'll just hold it up for those of you who are participating from home. And I find these stories, and there are a hundred stories about women starting from the time of the Buddha to some contemporary women. And after each story is a commentary by a contemporary woman teacher. So it's a very rich resource. And I just want to quote something that Florence Kaplow said about this book.

[09:58]

When unheard voices are heard, we all benefit. And Sue Moon and Florence Kaplow had to do a lot of searching to find these 100 stories. I think once they found these, they began realizing there were many more. But most of them are stories we might not know about. And she also said, the Dharma is a living thing, and we are making it. It's up to us. Each generation turns the Dharma. So the stories that we may who we bring from our own practice and experience are part of the Dharma that will be available for the next generations. And I think as an older person, an older woman, I'm very aware of the importance of supporting the next generations of women and practitioners to become leaders and teachers.

[11:07]

So the dharma keeps flowing, hopefully long after I'm no longer here. So the first story I'll just say to give you a little bit of an overview, I'm going to share a story first of a woman, a Chinese woman ancestor, and then two contemporary women, one of whom many of you may have known, Maylee Scott, who practiced here, and the other, Darlene Cohen, who practiced at San Francisco's ancestor. And then I'll come back to Mahapajabhati, our first woman ancestor. So the first story from The Hidden Lamp that I'll refer to is called The Old Woman's Relatives. And this woman wasn't named, so we don't know her name.

[12:09]

She lived in China in the 9th century. And this is the story in brief. Once a monk on pilgrimage met an old woman living alone in a hut. The monk asked, do you have any relatives? And she said, yes. The monk asked, where are they? She answered, the mountains, rivers, and the whole earth, the plants and trees, all are my relatives. So what can we learn from this old woman, you know, who apparently was living alone, but really she wasn't living alone, you know, given all of the world around her that she felt connected to. And Florence Kaplow wrote the reflection on this story, and she noted that in all the stories of old Chinese Buddhist hermits, this is the only one I know where the hermit is a woman.

[13:23]

A woman in China under Confucian law was subject from birth to death to the absolute will of male family members. father, husband, brother, son. This was also true in India in the time of Buddha. The monk may have thought she wouldn't survive on her own, thus the question about whether she had relatives nearby. But when the old woman turns the monk's question on its head, we know immediately that she is a Zen adult, a teacher. He didn't worry, she has relatives. She isn't unsupported, and none of us really is, however we may feel if we think about all the support that is available to us, both from the people that we know and the earth, the air, the water, the elements.

[14:30]

So this sense of being connected to all of life is one of the keys to experiencing longevity without misery, in my opinion. It's true that as we age, we may lose family members and friends to death. We may relocate to a place and leave some of our close friends and family behind. Yet if we are aware of all the beings that support us wherever we are, we're less likely to feel that isolation. And Florence Catlow, in her commentary, talked about meeting this sense of being cut off as a more pernicious sense of separation that comes from ideas of here and there. i and not i were the old women's were the old woman's relatives out there beyond her skin or somewhere closer by so i i this is um just a personal reflection about this i was quarantined

[15:57]

after testing positive for COVID in September. And because I live in a building with many other people, I moved up the street. San Francisco's Ed Center has a building with some apartments in it. And I was quarantined in one of those apartments. I felt after a few days when I wasn't feeling as sick as I was initially, I felt just so isolated and it was helpful to go outside and just take a walk in the neighborhood and to hug a tree in the park across the street. notice what was growing in the gardens, hear the bird calls, feel the wind on my face, and I realized I wasn't alone.

[17:03]

So I think that old woman in ninth century China has an important teaching for us as does Florence's reflection. So in 2014, I attended a Hidden Lamp workshop. So Florence, Kaplow, and Sumud, after the book was published, traveled around and did many workshops so that people could get to know these stories and draw from them. And in one of those workshops, I attended which was led by Florence. There was a time to write about a woman who had inspired us. And I wrote a piece about May Lee Scott.

[18:10]

So when I moved to the Bay Area in 1990, I became involved with the Buddhist Peace Fellowship. And May Lee was a pillar of the Buddhist Peace Fellowship. And At one point, she was going to the women's jail in San Francisco once a week to offer meditation instruction. And I asked if I could go with her. I wanted to volunteer as she was doing. For a year I went with her and I learned so much from her. So the woman I wrote about in this workshop with Florence was May Lee, and I'll just share what I wrote.

[19:12]

May Lee was unfazed by the whispering and giggling of the women in the cell during the time she had designated for silent meditation. I looked around at the women in their orange sweatshirts with irritation. Why was it so hard for them to sit still and be quiet? I asked myself. May Lee calmly and kindly reminded them to notice their breath as it entered their nostrils and as it left. Eventually the room did become quiet. She showed me by her example that calmness and kindness can transform people. Later, when she led a check-in, she listened with attention to the women's stories, visits from their children, hearing about the illness of a family member they were unable to see, hearing they would or would not be released from jail.

[20:14]

She modeled nonjudgmental, open-minded, and open-hearted connection. I could see that she liked these women. on the ride home every week, crossing the Bay Bridge in her old reliable car. We talk about our class, and again, I could appreciate her fearlessness and openness. It really helped me stretch. So, Lawrence's comment in the workshop was that life can hand you a hard deck of cards and you can still love. And I think that was one of, I don't know that maybe these

[21:25]

was so difficult, I think, in her life. She was also a social worker and well-educated and had a family. But she could be present with whoever she encountered. That was my sense. of Meili just fully present and open and available and a really inspiring teacher. So I recently visited Arcata Zen Center Meili after she was dharma transmitted here at Berkeley Zen Center. moved to Arcata and was the guiding teacher at Arcata's head center until she died.

[22:27]

And her spirit really lives on there. Many of the sangha, well, there's several sangha members who visit a prison nearby and are engaged in other ways in the community in Arcata. And another one of Florence Kaplow's teachers, who was also a teacher at San Francisco Center initially, and then she moved with her husband to a Russian river, Sandow, and that was Darlene Cohen. I don't know if any of you would have met Darlene. She lived in the city for a long time. When I first moved into city center, 1999 she was living there and right across the street with her husband Tony Patchell who worked in the tenderloin with people who were homeless or unhoused.

[23:41]

Darlene had a great sense of humor, very warm and friendly. And she also, she had rheumatoid arthritis, which she had gotten in her early 20s. And she really did a lot of work on what she calls suffering and delight, how to work with physical pain and um to notice whenever she entered a room something beautiful something in the space that she could focus on when she was in pain and she taught many people how to how to work with physical pain i wanted to read something from darlin's

[24:53]

story. And particularly, the reflection on this story was written by Leslie James, who's a teacher at San Francisco Zen Center. She mostly has been teaching at, living and teaching at Tassajara's and Mountain Center. And Leslie was a very close friend of Darlene's. So this is the story in Hidden Land. About two weeks before Darlene Cohen passed away, she was lying on the small sofa in her living room and a few students were there. In true form, Darlene announced matter-of-factly I don't believe in karma or any of that shit.

[25:54]

One of her students asked, if you don't believe in any of that, what do you believe in here on the threshold of life and death? Without a moment's hesitation and with much laughter and delight, Darlene said, I believe in skillful means, which means I'm willing to lie about anything. So she was, you know, in her own way, a very irreverent Zen teacher. And she was always surprising people. I think it was surprising because her teaching was kind of in your face, just really, how could be the word, fresh and unexpected sometimes, what she would say. So I'll just read a little bit of the commentary by Leslie James, who is another wonderful, wonderful teacher.

[27:06]

I don't know if any of you have had a chance to meet her. She is now spending less time at Tassajara because she has grandchildren that she loves to spend time with. but she was one of the people who inspired me when I first went to Tassajara. I met Darlene in the mid-70s when I first came to San Francisco's Zen Center, Leslie says. She was a really beautiful woman, vibrant and alive, and feisty. Then in her early 30s, When her son was only three years old, she developed rheumatoid arthritis. Her hands and legs were deformed and crippled, though she was still beautiful and lively. Eventually, years later, she had cancer, and the medicine for the cancer would counteract the medicine for the arthritis.

[28:08]

She had to keep choosing which one to take. Through it all, she would say, I'm going to live my life completely. I think she was surprised over time to find herself becoming a teacher. She had a lot of trust in her wisdom, but actually found herself being beneficial to people in a practice way surprised her. And as I watched her over the years, this came to be the most important thing to her. teaching people and helping people. She really studied how to make the Dharma available to people because she knew it had helped her so much. She did it in her own way though, with her own skillful means. So I'm fortunate to have met Darlene and have been inspired by her frankness and her

[29:12]

zest for life and her seemed unstoppable energy even though she did actually need to rest quite a bit when she was giving a talk or teaching a class she was so vibrant and um had so much joy in life so um I'm going to end with a story about Mahapajapati, who is our first woman ancestor. When we chant the women ancestors, it's Mahapajapati. And then so many of the Indian women who were part of her sangha. And there's a story about Mahapajapati in The Hidden Lamp as well.

[30:13]

It's called Mahapajapati Opens the Door. And it's about the story of her going to the Buddha three times to ask for the ordination of women. Maybe some of you are familiar with this story. And it's such a touching story and I'm going to share it as it was written in the hidden lamp. Maha Pujapati was the aunt and foster mother of the Buddha and a queen of the shakyas. Many women turned to her for counsel when their husbands and son left home to join the Buddha's order. She was the first to ask the Buddha if women could also ordain.

[31:16]

The Buddha replied, don't set your heart upon this. She asked two more times and received the same answer. She departed in tears. Later, Mahapajatati and 500 other women, 500 is just a term for many women, cut off their hair, put on saffron-colored robes, and walked barefoot for hundreds of miles to where the Buddha was teaching. Weeping, they stood outside the gates. Ananda, who was the Buddha's attendant, saw them there and asked Mahapajapati, why are you crying? Because the Buddha does not permit women to ordain. Ananda went to the Buddha and said, Your aunt is standing outside with swollen feet covered with dust, crying because you do not permit women to ordain.

[32:19]

It would be good, Lord, if women had permission to ordain. The Buddha replied, Enough, Ananda. Don't set your heart on this. Ananda asked two more times to no avail. Then he asked, Are women able, Lord, to realize the full fruits of the way, even arahachip? Yes, Ananda, they are, the Buddha said. Since women are able to realize perfection, and since Mahapajamati was so kind to you, caring for you and suckling you at her own breasts, surely it would be good if women were allowed to ordain. The Buddha remented. and the Saga of Women was born. So, great thanks to Maha Pajavati and to all the women who practiced with her and were able to ordain and that

[33:33]

question is still a live question in some of the countries of Asia where women are not allowed to ordain. So I feel, again, fortunate, greatly fortunate to be not only in a time and place where we as women can take our places and become teachers, whether we're ordained or not ordained. Mahapajapti paved the way for many younger women. And I'm going to share a poem from this collection. It's called The First Free Women. And it's poems of the early Buddhist nuns.

[34:36]

The one about Mahapajapati, I think it's quite beautiful. Mahapajapati, protector of children. I know you all. I have been your mother, your son, your father, your daughter. You see me now in my final role, kindly grandmother. It's a fine part to go out on. You might have heard how it all began when my sister died and I took her newborn son to raise as my own. People still ask, did you know then what he would become? What can I say? What mother doesn't see the Buddha in her child? He was such a quiet boy.

[35:42]

The first time he reached for me, the first time I held him while he slept, how could I not know? To care for all children without exception, as though each will someday be the one to show us all the way home. This is the path. So as we age, no matter what age we are, I think it's important to mentor younger generations. And for me, to be able to move aside or move back to enable younger generations to take up our leadership roles. to give them space to do that in their own ways while being available if they have questions or need us. And I think that's, I'm not a parent, but I think that's probably the essence of parenting as well, you know, to mentor the next generation and give them help when needed, but no one to step out of the way.

[37:00]

Do you think of longevity as a blessing? And I guess I feel fortunate to have lived this long. I do think of it as a blessing. And also think of words that Florence Kaplow shared that sometimes life can give you a hard deck and you can still love so um that's where i'd like to end my talk and open the um possibility of having some dialogue and comments questions whatever we'd like to share and if you would when when You ask a question, start with your name.

[38:05]

I don't know everybody's names who's here today. I can see you more clearly. And is it possible for people who are participating online by Zoom, you can also raise your hand. So I see, but I can't see your name, the person Green Rock Sue. Yes, Leslie. Hi, Leslie. Yes, people who are online can raise their digital hand. And if that's something you'll see, I'm not quite sure, but if you don't call on them, I can let you know that they have their hand up. Great. Thank you, Leslie. If there are any questions, comments in the center, you can just raise your real hand.

[39:10]

Yes, Mary. I'm Mary. The story about Mahapajapati, I always get stopped at the point where the Buddha says, don't set your heart on this. And then he says it again to Ananda. And then the word that is used in the hidden lamp is that he relents. So how do we work with that? With the Buddha who lived obviously in a cultural, the imperfect Buddha. Excuse me, excuse me. Could I make a request that the person who's asking the question for a moment just lower their mask so that we can hear?

[40:12]

Because I just would love to hear what you just ask and I can't speak. Oh, okay. I'll say it again. Thank you. I was saying that I always get stopped at the point in the story about Mahabajapati where the Buddha says, don't set your heart on that and it turns her away. And he does it then repeatedly with Ananda. And in the story, the story is told that finally he relents. I mean, that's the word. Right. So my question is, how do we work with the imperfect Buddha, the Buddha who is in a cultural, who is bound in cultural ways, but who also saw that women could be on the path? I mean, that... I don't know. Maybe I'm just naming the feeling that arose. Yes. Could you online hear the question? You can. Okay. So I think the Buddha had this fixed views about women, which were part of the culture in which he was raised.

[41:24]

And... I think many of us have fixed views about other people that we may not even be aware of and may not be open to possibilities that we might miss in other people. So I think I really appreciate that Ananda didn't stop asking that Buddha. and that he could see the qualities that women had to be leaders and uh that um you know even when the buddha remunted um there was still any special rules from women they at that time were not fully equal um but i think to have some um

[42:27]

understanding of the conditioning the Buddha was part of. You know, men and women were not equal in that time and in some places still were not treated equally. I think that he was willing, the fact that he was willing to admit that He was seeing things in a narrow way. It enables me to feel appreciation for the Buddha that he finally did. And sometimes it takes, I know sometimes I have a view of someone and I may be really seeing that person in a very limited way. And someone else may help me at times to be more open to that person. And I think all of us may have that kind of experience, you know, when we kind of have a fixed idea about somebody in our lives, and it can change.

[43:42]

But sometimes we need a nudge or, you know, someone else who sees the goodness of that person or the potential of that person. So I think it's also a lesson that even someone as insightful and wise as the Buddha had limitations and that eventually he could open his mind, that we can open our minds when we find ourselves prejudiced against some person or group of people. Thank you for that question. Yes. Hi, I'm Elisa. Elisa, hi Elisa, I can recognize you now. This directly spoke to what came to me as you spoke about Darlene Cohen, because I'm here because she taught at Green Gulch an amazing session for people who are practicing in pain.

[44:49]

And I had been practicing Zen before, but was unable to sit cross-legged any longer and felt that I no longer qualified to enter the way because it was so rigid. Especially, I associate this with Green Dolch, the need to hold onto the forms had made it very difficult for people with physical disabilities. And Darlene walked that line. She showed an incredible practice. She said, there's no excuse for not practicing. Sitting, standing, walking or lying down. Practice the way with joy. And I think as we enter into a time where women's place in the culture is attempting to be squelched again, we're going to encounter this in lots of ways.

[45:53]

I think your teaching on this today was very timely. Thank you. And it's definitely connected to seeing the Buddha in the same way, right? I think we all need to hold this in a very big container. Thank you. You're welcome. Could everyone hear what Lisa said? Yes. Oh, great. It's wonderful that those of you who are in the wider center can participate. so fully in here, what we're bringing up. So we can call on Elizabeth first and then Karen. Yeah. It's on Elizabeth. Thank you, Jova. As you grow older, as a teacher, as a woman, how has your relationship This might be too big of a question, but do you feel your relationship to teaching, how has it changed or widened or any kind of comment on your relationship to being a teacher and a leader in the wisdom of growing old?

[47:18]

Wow. I won't set my heart on an answer. Well, for one thing, I've stopped pretty much writing out all my talks. And trying to... Because I feel that... And I did read some things today, of course, but that I want to be in eye contact with people I'm talking to, talking with. I sometimes tell stories from my own

[48:22]

my own experience. As a student, I didn't do that today, but I feel that I'm still learning. I hope I always will be learning, and that I learn from each person I meet. So I learned something. you know, by living in community, I feel I learned something about my own likes and dislikes and how not to be limited by them. You know, people constantly surprise me and to be aware of when I feel some resistance to somebody to look at what's going on for me and what is that bringing up for me and how can I be curious about that person and find a way to connect with them.

[49:48]

I do really take and try to take seriously the idea of making space for the next generation of leaders and you know at City Center I still I love to be Kokyo and in the morning for morning service I have Kokyo one day a week and I'm I know that there are people who would love to be Kokyo, so I'm going to actually think about giving up being Kokyo for a while, or maybe for a long while. And making space in whatever way I can for other people to take on those roles, which are valuable and good learning. I don't know if that answers your question, but I hope I will always be open to learning something new and being aware of my own biases so I can question them.

[51:05]

Thank you. So I saw Karen and then Helen. Why don't you go first? I'm Hannah. Hannah, sorry. Hannah. Yeah, this sort of relates to your question, but I think for me, the main area of struggle to keep faith in the practice is really examining the more recent history of harm to women. the lineage that I started practicing in and this lineage and at my former place of practice I brought up this question and people were quite receptive to it but I didn't feel satisfied I don't with the answer that I think I was getting a lot which was that you know

[52:19]

These male teachers are not free from the causality of karma just because they're awake. And I don't know if I'll... I guess I just wanted to ask in a room full of women, yeah, how you... to understand these events that have occurred, you know, since the famous Japanese teachers came, you know, to America to teach, I guess, white Americans and how that kind of played out. So you're talking about sexual abuse. Yeah. It isn't only the Japanese teachers. Well, I meant it started, or at least in my lineage, it started with that.

[53:24]

It may be different here. Yeah, I don't think it started with the Suzuki Bashi in this lineage, but there have been certainly Richard Baker and there have been other teachers. I'm not so sure. Yeah, there have been. So I think it's... a very painful area for not only Zen sambhas, but this is more widespread. And I think there's more of an understanding that this needs to be talked about when it occurs and that there's no move for some, I think there's some, how do I put it, that there are consequences for a teacher who

[54:48]

mistreats or abuses or makes overtures toward a student. And it's usually male teachers and women students, but not exclusively. And to really address those issues in a samba when they come up. And I think there's much more or less tolerance for that kind of transgression now. I don't know that there ever was tolerance, but it was harder to talk about. I think now women are more likely to bring it up when that occurs and then it's not ignored. At least I know that's true at San Francisco Center. This has happened a couple of times, at least. I don't really, my 20-some years of residence, I can think of a couple of instances where, you know, teachers crossed a line that was not acceptable, and they were asked to step down, not wear their robes.

[56:17]

and get some help and it's like you know therapy and it wasn't ignored i think that's something that's changing there's no tolerance for that for um overstepping um those boundaries in and i think it's also part of the Me Too movement. It's wider in our society now, more widely addressed. I'm wondering, did you want to hear from other people who are in the room? Because there may be other people who'd like to say something about this. Yeah, Karen? And then, finale. I know I've felt unwelcome advances here, and I've been here a very long time, so we're going back a ways, not recently.

[57:30]

But I remember a priest in robes who was consistently inappropriate, and I just, I think it has to be talked about and talked about that people shouldn't swallow that. I'm thinking of you, but also anyone else that that happens to, that it shouldn't be some secret or cause of shame or, I don't know, that's what I would say to the group that's here right now. Thank you. I come initially from a tradition in Southern California, the center of Los Angeles, and we did have, before I was there, the Roshi had sexual relations with

[58:40]

a senior student and the daughter of another senior student. And initially, and this is, I think, a pattern that has existed in other places as well, was very challenging at first for the senior students to come forward and to really get it out in the open and addressed. And finally, it erupted. And the... piece of good news around it is many times when you hear these stories, the person who's perpetrated has never openly atoned or acknowledged, sort of been done behind doors a little bit, if at all. And to his credit, I think, Maizumi Roshi atoned publicly over and over again and sat through people confronting him in many, many So there was that at least possibility for healing, although great damage was done at the time.

[59:52]

So I think part of exactly what Karen was saying was true to me as well, that when the very first inkling of this kind of treatment, emerges in any place, not just in the Sangha, in any place that it becomes spoken, it becomes public, it becomes, so the person is supported, who's been perpetrated against in any way, is deeply supported, but also that it opens the possibility to healing eventually. Thank you for asking this question. Yeah, Mary? I think it's also important that we don't have to make up a response every time it happens, that we actually have a structure in place that is built in and the way that we've built it in here over the last, I don't know, two and a half decades is by having

[61:05]

an ethics committee that stands actually on its own supervised by the board but not by the habit so that if there is some problem in leadership there's a place to go that isn't directed by leadership but is directed by you know another group and that can handle and look into the situation and then determine and make a determination about what should happen so that you don't, I mean, in the early days, my understanding of what happened at San Francisco Zen Center is that part of the problem was figuring out how to address it, who to get together in the room, who had authority, who could make something happen, and that actually is a structural problem. that needs to be built into a sangha to make it safe.

[62:06]

Yeah, thank you for that respect. Does anyone else want to speak to this question? Anyone online? Yes. Hi, I'm Erna. Hi, I'm Erna. Hi, I'm Erna. Um, speak louder. So, um, I'm, I'm new. Thank you, Mary, for sharing the structural thing. Cause what, what I just wanted to share, what occurs to me is what they're finding now about how the brain is structured and, you know, how our brains work is that people in power tend to lose awareness. of even like themselves and their behaviors. So I think we can, in a way, like not be, that to me says, well, we can maybe not, I guess people need to atone for and be responsible for their behavior, but it gives that little bit of like, oh, this is something that a group has to help this person with.

[63:20]

So then that mean to me, so I'm really glad to hear that here at this center, that that structure is there because Just that little, in my mind, just that little turning, oh, it's not like some person who's... We're all possibly susceptible to this if we are in a position of power. Well, nobody's giving us feedback because our perceptions will change. Thank you. Any other comments, questions? So I'm just... I'm aware that we're a little bit over time for this part of the program. Is that okay? It's fine. It's okay. Did you see another hand? Yes.

[64:20]

My name is Hema, and I just wanted to say that To me, besides the structural need of having a group, there's always what is left inside of you. That's really the impact of the experience. And I've had to look at the shadow side of myself, too. Like, why is this happening? And the sitting has been very helpful just to really let there's some kind of acceptance that needs to happen. Not acceptance in a passive way, but even if the Sangha is addressing it and everything, there's always something like, why did this happen? So that kind of turmoil that goes inside is something that for me, the practice has really been very helpful, just to deal with it.

[65:24]

Thank you, Hannah. I think we probably should at this point. Okay. So I appreciate your bringing up that question. Thank you. And of all the responses. And thank you all for your attention. And so we'll close the talk with a chant. I vow to sing with them. Delusions are inexhaustible.

[66:11]

@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_89.58