You are not logged in. You can log in or create an account to save favorites and join collections. more info
Aspects Class 1 of 4 Ordinary Bodhisattvas
The talk presents metta as a cultivable, relational practice of goodwill that supports ease and helps reduce suffering; it emphasizes practical, sustainable methods rather than forcing affection, including brief phrases or somatic attention to warmth. It situates metta within the four Brahmaviharas and connects its cultivation to Zen practice, emotional regulation, and compassionate presence toward others.
Texts and works referenced
- Dhammapada — Its opening verses link mental states and actions to suffering or happiness and state that hatred ends through non-hatred.
- Four Foundations of Mindfulness — Its instructions to observe internally and externally are interpreted as including awareness of other people, underscoring the relational dimension of practice.
- Buddhaghosa, Visuddhimagga (The Path of Purification) — Chapter 9 describes the divine abidings and a traditional sequence for extending metta; the talk questions some of its restrictions and its assumption that practice should begin with oneself.
- Anguttara Nikaya, “Rajan Sutta” — The teaching that beings hold themselves dear supports the instruction not to harm others; the discussion also considers whether self-directed metta is accessible to everyone.
- Daniel Goleman, Healing Emotions — Recounts a discussion about self-hatred and the difficulty some practitioners face in beginning metta with themselves.
- Lotus Sutra, chapter 25 — Avalokiteshvara’s responsive action is cited in relation to compassionate engagement with others.
- Ayya Khema, Dharma talk on love — Describes love as a quality of the heart cultivated continuously, whether or not there is an immediate opportunity to express it.
- Yoga Sutras of Patanjali — Mentioned as another source in which the Brahmaviharas appear, indicating that these practices predate Buddhism.
- Metta Sutta — Identified as a canonical teaching specifically devoted to metta.
Teachers and authors referred to
- Buddhaghosa — Cited for classical instructions on cultivating the Brahmaviharas.
- Ayya Khema — Cited for the distinction between cultivating a loving heart and actively directing goodwill in a particular moment.
- Shunryu Suzuki — Referred to for teachings on warm-heartedness in zazen and care in transmitting practice.
- Sojun Mel Weitsman — Cited for describing metta as an ongoing orientation expressed through whatever one is doing.
- Analayo — Cited for interpreting mindfulness of the body internally and externally as including one’s own body and the bodies of others.
- Dalai Lama, Sharon Salzberg, Jon Kabat-Zinn, and Daniel Goleman — Referred to in an account concerning Western practitioners’ difficulty with self-directed loving-kindness.
AI Suggested Title: Cultivating Goodwill in Everyday Practice
So we'll start with the Sutra, help me verse. An unsurpassed, measuring, and perfect karma is rarely met with, even in a hundred thousand million kalpas, having it to see and listen to, to remember and thank you for coming. Everybody in the zendo and everybody in the zundo. It's lovely to see you all. This is our class called Ordinary Bodhisattvas, the Brahma Viharas in Action. So when we were asked to teach this class and aspects of practice, practice period, well, this was an idea we've been sort of
[01:08]
working with for a while. And then we thought, oh, Aspects of Practice is four weeks, there's four classes, there's four Brahma Viharas. That's nice. That'll work. So that's what we're going to do at Brahma Viharas. As I think most of you know, teaching in Buddhism, but even prior to Buddhism, sometimes called the sublime emotions. It literally means the abodes of Brahma. And they are metta, karuna, udita, upekka in Pali language. Almost the same in Sanskrit. I think Sanskrit metta is maichi. and upeka is spelt differently. That's as much as I know.
[02:09]
And of course, they mean love or loving kindness, compassion, joy or sympathetic joy, and equanimity. So these are states of mind that are at the same time our birthright, but we're all endowed with, but we all have the capacity to access and that can be cultivated. It can be cultivated, our ability to access the sublime emotions. It can be cultivated. So this is what we're really interested in in this class. Like we said before, Sojan Roshi would always say his favorite question is how, not what or why, but how. How do we practice this? How do we engage with this? And yeah, a big, Part of why we chose this is the state of the world right now.
[03:09]
There's a lot of hate going around. There's a lot of division going around. There's a lot of anxiety, dysregulation. I think, you know, everybody feels this. Anyway, I certainly do. So I shouldn't say everybody. I feel it. I'm feeling that. and maybe many of you are as well. And so we thought, well, you know, how do we deal with this? How do we meet these feelings? How do we meet our anxiety and distress? So these are tools, things that we can cultivate and access to help us and to help each other. So in this class and in this aspects of practice period, we really want to put the emphasis on the how and the engaging and in relationship.
[04:22]
How do we do this with each other? How do we support each other in perilous times? And, you know, I could say, so I have a little bit of a personal ulterior motive in wanting to teach this and practice this with y'all, which is I'm not very good at it personally. I don't think I'm very good at it. So I recognize that I want to be able to cultivate love, loving kindness. And I want to be better at it. I want to be more effective at it. When I, not too long ago, gave away Seeking Mind talk and I shared some of my personal life. And, you know, I could say in my family, we didn't hear the words I love you very much at all. You know, just didn't happen.
[05:24]
So I actually trained my father to say it. I'm certain nobody ever told him. I'm certain he never heard those words growing up. So when I was living in San Francisco, definitely not practicing Buddhism, and my dad happened to be sometimes cohabitating with this woman who lived in the Brooklyn Hills in a house that definitely burned down in the big fire. And she was an interesting person. Yeah, my dad was just across the bay. I'd come see him sometimes. We'd hang out, and I'd leave, and the last thing I'd say before I leave was, I love you. And he said, I love you too. He got really excited. So it got so like, I would go and visit with him, and I'd be getting ready to leave. I could tell he was waiting for it. He's like, it's gonna happen, it's gonna happen.
[06:28]
Yeah, because, because, People want that. People need that. So yeah, I would like to be more effective in that. So thank you. So one of the things that I also wanted to, one of the reasons that I wanted to study this all, to practice this all with all of you is because I noticed that with all of the stuff that's going on in the world, It seems like many of us all at one time are a little off balance just because there's been so much going on. So it's not as readily available that we can feel a little off balance and call up any one of our friends and know that they'll be regulated for us because we have known that they're going through some stuff too. However, they're handling it. So I do know that being in contact with somebody who's
[07:29]
calm, grounded, and loving, it shifts my whole way of being. And I want to be that for other people, too. And the times when I have been, in any small or large way, it lifts me, it lifts them, and it's such a good feeling. But it takes a little practice to be able to do that. I mean, literally practice. Getting yourself used to how you settle into it. I used to be a body worker, I used to do massage therapy, and I used to really run late for things a lot. So I was often like sitting at my table and just like, I barely had it, I was working from home, barely had it together before this person was coming to the door. And I learned that with the first touch of my hands on their back, that I would ground there. And I could. After a while, that was actually like I was there.
[08:30]
So I'm like, wow, this is amazing. You can learn to do these things. Because I tend to run hot. My nervous system runs speedy. So practice is powerful. And this is the area that we want to explore for practice, is how this practice can be powerful for all of us, how we can support each other and the world. I want to start with just a little bit of context for the Brahmavaharas. Another name for them is the four immeasurables. So these are like the four divine states, the immeasurables. These are like beautiful, expansive states of mind, as Greg said, love or loving kindness, compassion, joy or sympathetic joy, and equanimity. I want to start back with one of the Buddha's very early teachings from the Dhammapada. And the opening of the Dhammapada, which is thought to be some of the earliest teachings of the Buddha.
[09:34]
And the first part is in this kind of verse form. And many of you have probably heard this before. All experience is preceded by mind, led by mind, made by mind. Speak or act with a corrupted mind and suffering follows as the wagon wheel follows the hoof of the ox. All experience is preceded by mind, led by mind, made by mind. Speak or act with a peaceful mind and happiness follows like a never-departing shadow. He abused me, he attacked me, defeated me, robbed me. For those carrying on like this, hatred does not end. She abused me, attacked me, defeated me, robbed me. For those not carrying on like this, hatred ends.
[10:38]
Hatred never ends through hatred. By non-hate alone does it end. This is an ancient truth. So what we do, acts of body, speech and mind, matters. It has an effect on us, it has ripple effects on the world. And that can go in a positive direction, it can go in a negative direction. If we take a step on the path to suffering, suffering increases. If we take a step, even just one step, on the path to freedom from suffering, happiness increases, freedom increases. So there are many lists in the Pali Canon, the earliest Buddhist teachings, because it was all in the world tradition at that time. So lists were a good way to keep track of things. And a lot of Buddhism actually — the Buddha didn't make up all of this.
[11:43]
He used a lot of things that were already ready to hand, and often gave them a little different interpretation, a little different touch. So the Brahmaviharas are older than Buddhism, actually, and they show up in different places as well. They also appear in the Yoga Sutras of Pantajali. So these are really fundamental teachings that were widespread throughout Asia. back then and today also. So these attitudes are very relational. Love, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. It's how we relate to things and how we relate in relationship. So How do we practice, how do we cultivate having a wholesome attitude toward whatever arises, but particularly with the Brahmaviharas, it's toward people, how this manifests in another person.
[12:54]
But it also expands to everything. If we can have an attitude of friendliness toward our knees when they hurt, or toward the thoughts that arise in our mind, that attitude of friendliness or compassion It goes everywhere. So in the West, practice generally, like Buddhist meditation and stuff, is often taught as a very individualized, internal sort of practice. And people often talk about my practice. How's your practice going? How's my practice going? Because in many cases, that's the completely appropriate place to start with one's self. But Buddhist practice has always been deeply relational. The Vinaya, the codes of conduct for fully ordained monks and nuns are, they're really relational. A lot of them are how you relate with the things of everyday life, how you relate to washing and collecting alms, how you relate to people, to other monks, to the teacher, to your bowls.
[14:07]
So it's all about how you relate with them and very specific as to what you do. So that particular practice is how do you embody this? Just as when we're in the zendo, there's all these guidelines about how to and away from your cushion and maintain silence in the zendo. All of these kinds of things are to create a particular kind of container and relationship that supports freedom from suffering. Over and over the Buddha said, I teach only one thing, suffering and freedom from suffering. So there's another early sutra from the Buddha called the Four Foundations of Mindfulness. And it's a series of very specific instructions for where to place your awareness in practice. and like the breath and the body.
[15:12]
And as you go through it, and early Buddha sutras tend to be repetitious, so that it really kind of drums it in and you can memorize it. So this verse, which repeats for every individual instruction, has a part that says something like, this is how a practitioner observes the body in the body, She observes the body internally, externally, and both internally and externally. And the interpretation of what that means, internally and externally, has really gone toward the one I'm going to share with you, which comes from Analio, who did a lot of research, Vigo Analio. And he says that internally is within our own body, and externally is in another's body. So we're really being with our own breath, another's breath, choosing to place our attention there.
[16:17]
And for me, that was just a revelation about how fundamentally relational Buddhist practice is, that in these early, early instructions, we're not just observing ourselves, but we're being deeply with others as well. Breathing together. Yeah. The Buddhist conspiracy. Right? That's what that word means, breathing together. Yeah. It's beautiful. And I forgot to mention, please interrupt us. Yes, Ross. A little bit louder for you over for you. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah. Don't hesitate. We'd like this class very much to be interactive, to exchange ideas, to share things.
[17:19]
Go ahead. Which word did you say the inspiration to? Conspire. To conspire. Conspiration. Inspire. Expire. Perspire. But it literally means breathing together. What you just said about the body and the body. I was talking to someone a few years ago and he was relating to that phrase as thinking about our nervous system, which is in the shape of our body and is sort of like a body in our body. And thinking about it relationally, our nervous systems do respond to each other. And we can sense when a person's mood or the way our mood can ripple out. Kind of what you're talking about, that calm presence. It just made me think of that.
[18:24]
Thank you. On the tech side, perhaps if people who have masks on take them off, their voice will project and then we'll hear them more online. And also, people online would like to ask a question. or anything, a virtual hand, and maybe Blake could catch it? Most definitely, yeah. Thank you. Thank you, Ross. So, we're talking about how to practice. How do we engage with this? And this is something that Buddhist practitioners have been doing for many centuries. So, take you back to Buddhaghosa, for example, the fifth century of the common era in Sri Lanka wrote this amazing tome called the Visuddhimaga or the path of purification. I used to jokingly call this the boy scout manual for Buddhist monks. It covers everything.
[19:25]
It's very, very exhaustive, extensive. Everything you need to know to be a good monk. And a lot of it. it remains entirely relevant this day. And a lot of it, not so much. At one point in Tassajara, a practice period led by the abbess, Linda Ruth Cutts, she said a couple of times, Buddhism is an open canon. The teachings are not finished or dead. They're being added to all the time. So this is really up for us, for this class, very much up for us, is what is serving us now in the 21st century.
[20:27]
Not like we're out to change things up for the sake of it, or just like, let's make it different because we can. No. Not at all. In fact, Suzuki Roshi said, it will change, and please be careful with it. And if you're in doubt, just revert to the Japanese, he said, to be on the safe side. But of course, we can see that it is changing a lot. A simple example is chanting the names of women ancestors. They don't actually do that in Japan. They're not doing that in Soto Zen in Japan. So, anyway, these are the roots. Buddha Gosna talks about the four foundations. I mean, the Brahma Viharas and the four foundations. But how to practice the Brahma Viharas in particular. I'm not going to read this whole thing.
[21:28]
It's a lot. He has a lot of advice, and some of it I agree with, and some of it I don't agree with. It's chapter 9, Description of Concentration, the Divine Abidings. For example, he says, you should not practice extending loving kindness to a person of the opposite sex. Too dangerous. Slippery slope. I don't think I agree with that. Or interestingly, he says, don't practice loving kindness for a dead person. Oh, why not? Well, he says, you're not likely to make any headway. Says that right here. But classically,
[22:32]
classically, and you'll hear this in many places, and this is kind of the beginnings, the source. Buddhaghosa says, first of all, it should be developed only towards oneself, doing it repeatedly. Thus, may I be happy and free from suffering, or may I keep myself free from enmity, affliction, and anxiety, and live happily. Very nice. And then, you know, he says you should start with yourself and then extend it classically. You'll hear this many places to someone you care about a lot, you know, someone who's very dear to you, someone who's important to you, like a teacher, a friend, a lover, and then someone who's
[23:33]
neutral, like the person at the corner store takes your money, gives you your soda pop. You know, you're friendly, but you're not exactly that. That's my best friend, but a neutral, a neutral person. And then someone who's difficult, right? Doesn't have to be super difficult, just, you know, maybe a little bit difficult. Do the practice that's then you can sustain. It's practical. Don't shoot too high. But this business about starting with yourself, it's interesting. He says, if she develops it in this way, I'm happy. Just as I want to be happy and dread pain, I want to live and not to die, so do other beings too. making oneself the example, then desire for other beings' welfare and happiness arises in them.
[24:36]
And this method is indicated by the Blessed One saying, I've visited all quarters with my mind, nor found I any dearer than myself. Self is likewise to every other dear, who loves himself will never harm another. And that's from a very old Pali text from the Anguttara Nikaya. collection of suttas. It's called the Udana, Verses of Uplift. And these are super short suttas. They're the shortest suttas in the Pali canon. They're fun to read. So this is all from Access to Insight. There's actually a standalone volume that they had in the Tassajara library, but I couldn't find it. So I just went online. Access to Insight as the entire Holly Cannon. Close, maybe not the entire thing, but really close. It's a lot. And this one is called the Rajan Sutta, the king.
[25:39]
Should I read it? I can't help it. I have to. I've heard that on one occasion the Blessed One was staying near Savati at Jedha's Grove. And on that occasion, King Pasanadi Kosala had gone with Queen Malika to the upper palace. Then he said to her, Malika, Is there anyone dearer to you than yourself? No, great king. There is no one dearer to me than myself. And what about you, great king? Is there anyone dearer to you than yourself? No, Malika. There's no one dearer to me than myself. It goes on a little bit like this. I'm not going to redo the whole thing. But they're like, yep, we're in agreement. Let's go see what this Shaky Moody guy has to say about it. So they do. And that's what he says. He says, I'm realizing the significance of that. The Blessed One on that occasion exclaimed, searching all directions with your awareness, you find no one dearer than yourself. In the same way, others are thickly dear to themselves.
[26:44]
So you shouldn't hurt others if you love yourself. This is really good advice. But I'm not so sure it's advice that we can all take in, necessarily. So speaking of Buddhism being an open canon, there's a story that is so pervasive in Western convert Buddhism, I bet at least half the people here have heard this story. I'm willing to bet. I'm not a betting person, but I just got a strong suspicion. This is from a book by Daniel Goleman called Healing Emotions. where he describes this encounter between the Dalai Lama, Sharon Salzberg, Jon Kabat-Zinn and others. They're on this Mind Life Institute panel. And Sharon Salzberg asks the Dalai Lama, what about people who don't like themselves?
[27:45]
How do they practice? He was completely confused. This was in 1990. The Dalai Lama was completely confused, and they had to, like, convince him that it was a really pervasive problem in the West, self-hatred. And he was flabbergasted. Linda said he even cried. And then finally he says, I thought, the Dalai Lama said, I thought I had a very good acquaintance with the mind, but now I feel quite ignorant. So they had to explain to the Dalai Lama that people, exist who actually do not like themselves at all and if that's the case that might be difficult to start practicing metta for yourself and if that's the case don't do that you know buddha ghost has got some good advice but it's not necessarily gonna serve everybody so i don't know
[28:55]
What do you think, Linda? Should we do a breakout? Yeah, I think we should. Okay. So... You want to do that? Well, let's... So we wanted to... We want to really very strongly... We're not assigning homework in the traditional sense of like reading a text, although you're welcome to read, but really suggest that you take up a practice of metta. So tonight... we're gonna do a couple of breakout groups to support you to get very specific about what you're gonna do. That doesn't mean that you can't tweak it later, but that you walk out of here tonight having some idea what you're gonna do for the next four weeks, or at least for the next week, as we're working on compassion. A concept of a plan. A concept of a plan. No, I reject. We're gonna have a plan. I'm sorry, dumb joke, dumb joke. So in the breakout group, and we'll have two minutes each, two minutes each.
[30:00]
So one person will talk, then the other. And it's, where would you start? Do you want to start with yourself? Do you want to start with another person? It's really good to pick a person. And you can do more than one. But when you sit down to start your practice, in whatever way you do that, who are you going to start with? And why? A little bit about why. Like, why did you choose that? Well, I have a hard time with, you know, self-doubt and I'm going to challenge myself and just start there. Or, yeah, I've been doing this for a while and I want to continue this and deepen it. Or I have this difficult person in my life and I'm going to do this. Yeah, so where would you start and who else would you include and where will you do it? Will you do it when you're driving, when you're walking? Will you sit down and do it silently? Will it be incorporated into your life or will it be a dedicated time? Just to start thinking into it so that you can have some sense like, what am I going to do tomorrow?
[31:07]
Yes. Could you say your name please? Could you say your name please? James. James. I'm wondering when you say, what are you going to do? What is that like? What do you mean by do? What is the do? What practice might you take up? We'll talk more about what are the specifics of practice and two particular ways that people can practice. But just think, will you just focus on that for a period of time? Or will you do it when you're walking to work or driving or washing dishes or whatever? How can this be folded into your day in a way that works for you? So who and how? Jeremiah. I'm Jeremiah. That was my question, too. Is it both picking the person and what you're going to do, you're saying? Just how you're going to do it. Not like what you're going to do as a practice, but when you're going to do it during the day. So pick the person and when you're going to do it.
[32:08]
Yeah. The person or people. The person or people. Specificity is a good thing, actually. I mean, you can't do that. May all beings be happy. Of course, we chant that on a regular basis. Or, you know, may everybody in the city of Berkeley be peaceful and at ease. That's a nice thing. That is another form of metapractice where you go like bigger and bigger and bigger, you know, geographical areas. But to begin with, I think specificity is pretty good. You know, individuals, people you know, or if you're driving, that person who just cut me off. You don't have to know them exactly, but, you know, specifically. Ross. Thank you. I had a question earlier that I think folds into what we're about to do, which is, you doubted, Buddha said, don't waste time sending loving kindness to dead people. Yes. I heard you right. You disagreed with that. So I wanted to ask you then, ask you now, what's the benefit, or how does one
[33:15]
uh all for loving kindness either to literally dead people or people who are no longer in our life that we still have some residual stuff with and how does that benefit us and is there a benefit for those other people well i don't know about the benefit for the deceased that's an interesting thing to think about i mean some people say when we chanted dahi shindirani we are actually helping people who have gone beyond the veil uh many people believe that for sure uh however um for me the reason i was like i don't i don't i think it's fine personally um like i said um the talk i just gave soldier roshi said to me Death is not a big interrupter in a teacher-student relationship. That really hit home. And I think for also, like in talk therapy, when you're trying to resolve karma with, say, ancestors or parents or, you know, they're not around, somebody hurt you, you know, that's in the past.
[34:32]
And you say, oh, that's all dead and buried. Is it? Or is it still going on inside of you? And you still need to make peace with it. I think that you can, one tool for making peace with that is extending loving kindness. I see. Soji Roshi once said that people who've died are already on their way. So these services we do are actually for ourselves. So we're healing that. What happens with them, who knows? But it really does come back to the first thing, number one. Thank you. Thank you. Blake. Often, it seems superficial to me to do meta practice. Can you give some words about how it's actually impacted your life through the practice? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I'm not joking. I'm laughing, but it's not a joke. Linda was talking about driving, you know.
[35:33]
drove here from Monterey this afternoon through a whole lot of traffic. We had to go to Monterey because that's where our dentist is. And because we used to live in Tassajara. Anyway, there's a lot of driving and crummy traffic. And I was actually practicing meta. I think you should go out. You are clearly in a bigger hurry than me. I love you a lot. Please go ahead. you know, rather than tensing up. Oh, I'm not feeling so much tension on my shoulders. I feel fine, you know? Even after all that driving, I feel fine. So that's an immediate benefit for me. I mean, it's not just obviously selfishly motivated, but there is benefit, you know? And as like Linda was pointing to, If I'm more relaxed, if I'm more loving, then I can be that for other people.
[36:38]
And I want that. I want to live in that kind of world. I want to live in the kind of world where people say, I love you on a regular basis and mean it. So, you know, if you want to, if you want such a thing, get to work on such a thing, Dogen said. So, yeah, I think this practice is evergreen. And not the... Not something we talk about a lot in Zen. You know, we just say, you know, upright sitting, just this is it. But when you're doing that upright sitting, you don't know who else in the Zen might be wishing you metta all kinds of ways, you know, practicing it. I know I have. I know I have. During Zazen, I've done metta practice a lot. It helps me to calm the mind, the same as carrying my breath. Yeah. So I'm going to change my mind here. I think we should not do a breakout group right now.
[37:39]
We're not doing a breakout group? No. Because we're going to do a breakout group at the end and talk about what you're actually going to practice. We're going to do a breakout group. Because this is going to, we're just going to do a break. We're going to do a breakout group and then a break. We're just going to do a break. Okay. And we'll fold this in to what we do at the end. So, you've probably been thinking about giving some thought to this already. So, we'll fold that in to what we do at the end. I hope that's okay. Peter, you have a question. I have a question. I'm just going to say that I believe in one of Susan T. Rusty's lectures. He said, when you sit so often, cultivate a warm feeling towards yourself. And the first time I read that, it changed. Because I was one of these people that hated myself. And I would sit in Zazen hitting myself. That didn't change because I was in a nice posture. But that teaching, I started practicing that. And I just started looking for any kind of warmth I could find in my heart and just sending it down physically.
[38:41]
It was just initially physical practice of cultivating warmth toward myself. And it really changed the way I experienced Zazen. So I think that is, it's hidden in our practice. Yes. You want to talk more about that, right? Yes. Well, I can just say now that Subjim has given talks, I think more than one, where it'd be a little feisty to begin with. He said, I'm going to talk about love today. People have been complaining to me lately that I never talk about love. What are we doing every day? And he went on to list all the things we do. in the course of practice, you know, just all of these things. He said, it's all love all the time. He said, I don't like to use the word love because it can be sentimental. And that's what he didn't want, was to be sentimentalized. So I'll talk more about mental and love later.
[39:42]
So do you usually do like five minute breaks? Is that a couple of hands online? Okay. Hi there. Oh, can you see me? Yes. Okay, great. That's why we're looking this way. Okay. I'm on a very tidy phone. Thank you for this. I have been thinking about Metta and Tonglen and just various forms of compassion practices. There's someone in my life who I want to be able to do this for them. There's a deep wound. And when I start, I get nauseous. And I've probably tried about 40 times and I get nauseous after 10 to 20 seconds. And I would just appreciate your perspective on how to hold the very difficult
[40:49]
reality of, for me, wanting to be that person who wants that for that other person, but also, you know, I wonder if I'm doing harm to myself trying to force myself in that direction sometimes. I think you can just hold... your wish in your heart to be able to wish them well but that the main focus could be a deep love friendliness and compassion for the wound that you have suffered with this person and how deeply it's affecting you and just to to be with that and to wish yourself well and healing I trust that your wish to eventually be able to do this will not go away.
[41:53]
It's just at the right time. Thank you. Yeah. I don't like feeling nauseous myself. So I would say don't force anything, you know, and this, you know, but it goes, it does have good advice. Start with what's easy. Start with the easy one. Get comfortable with that. Get skillful with that, and then work your way up a little bit harder. Save that nausea-inducing one for . And then maybe when it's not nausea-inducing, seriously, then yeah, then you can go there. There's another hand. Hi, Gary. Gary. I just wanted to add to Peter's statement that Suzuki Roshi follows that with have warmer feelings for your breath.
[42:58]
Say that again. Suzuki Roshi follows have warm feelings for yourself and then he follows it have even warmer feelings for your breath. Oh, nice. Even warmer feelings for your breath. Yeah. Mel told me that Suzuki Roshi emphasized this warm-hearted feeling in Zazen a lot. Numerous images he would bring this up. Okay, so. Joe had a question. Joe. I want to ask what is love? Like, what are we talking about? We'll get to that, right? Because we're going to have this breakout room and talk about our practice. I'm like, well, what is it we're talking about? All right, cool. Break time? You don't need a break. I do. Okay, five minutes. Okay, 8.05.
[44:01]
You don't have to leave the Zendo, don't. You can do it. Go. This is good. I love it. Lots of questions. I love it. All right, let me see what's going on here. I've got a remote stand. I can get a remote stand. I've got [...] a remote stand.
[45:03]
I've got a remote stand. I've got a remote stand. I've got a remote stand. Thank you. Thank you. Do it. Yeah, that's it. Do it.
[46:04]
She's in there. She's got a . That's pretty much over your day. Thank you so much. It's a crime.
[47:04]
It's a crime. When they did the musical, for example, offline, Oh, God. And it's got a little bit of money on chair falls.
[48:22]
It's crazy. It's a little bit shorter. .
[49:41]
. [...] Thank you. How about the rest of these people today? They're back? Then all you have to do is ask Joe to ring a bell. All you gotta do is ring a bell. That's all right.
[50:44]
I was far away. I trust you would remember it. Thank you. Okay, we're ready to start. So, Jen, you perfectly anticipated what I was going to talk about. So, Mehta is... Oh, yes. I have a question. based on what we were talking about before. How does, I was gonna say, what's the difference, but it's not the difference that I'm wondering about, but how does it compare between, let's say you're driving, and people are driving like they drive, and it doesn't feel so great. How does it compare if you sort of send out, well, I'm, you know, I know you've probably inherited it somewhere, that's why,
[51:51]
you know, take care, as opposed to making a choice to, I'm not going to suffer and add to the suffering by getting all riled up. So there are two different ways, I think, to sort of get to the same place, but I don't know if one of them is more selfish or or if one of them is more thoughtful. So I'm curious your thoughts. I think they're both beneficial. And I think they can both happen together. Because when we get less irritated, then other people often calm down around us. And when we're generally wishing others well, we calm down. If it's genuine, then we tend to calm down. Do you think each different way is equally as beneficial in doing metta?
[52:59]
Sure. What's working for D? Yeah. I think that's the important question. Yeah. What's working for you? It's like, what's the best exercise in the world? The one you actually do. Yeah. Please. Yeah, my name's Renee. Hi Renee. So I have a question on how to handle, I guess, metta or like have this kind of open heart when one's dealing with myriad beings as it were. Like I'm a teacher in a high need school and so I'm kind of an empath and I want to help. So I'll be in the room and I'll be teaching and I can really pick up on like this student is in their stuff and this student needs this. So I instantly go, you know, like there's that, but then I end up feeling pulled and at times a bit derailed.
[54:04]
And so how do I hold, I guess I'm like, oh man, like I'm always wanting, you know, it's like it's, I'm always wanting good for these people, for everyone, right? there's this diffusion that happens within me as a result of going out. So I guess how do I navigate that? This is good material for next week. The next one is compassion. Karuna, which is what we're actually doing, what you're actually practicing in the classroom. When you said, relating to this student and that student. I thought of chapter 25, the Lotus Sutra, right away, aptly responding in every quarter. That's what Avalokiteshvara does. Right, and I think that part of the challenge is I'm struggling with how do I apply it to myself. Which essentially, in a way, what we're talking about right now.
[55:06]
Including all beings, all beings other than this one. And how do I help other people and help myself. And that's why the Buddha talked over and over again about skillful needs. Because all of these things are skills. When we cultivate certain states of mind, when we cultivate practices, we sit in sasa, we're developing, you know, we don't usually think of it that way, but we're developing specific skills of concentration, of where to pay attention, of having to sit with things, learning with it. You know, so we're always learning, every moment, So even if it doesn't go the way we wanted it to, we have an opportunity to learn each time because there will be something else that comes up. Okay. This is great. Love. Love. So, menta is often translated as love or loving kindness, but we get understanding of those words in a lot of different ways.
[56:11]
So I want to be as clear as I can about how I understand the Buddha Menta and how it's generally understood within Buddhism, as opposed to within this culture. And it's not that there isn't an overlap, but I want to be clear what the Buddha was talking about when he was sharing these practices. So Menta is a wish for happiness, true happiness, and I'll say more about that in a minute, for ourselves and everyone else. With metta for the entire universe, cultivate a limitless heart. So in Pali, the word metta is actually related to mita or friend. The word for love is pema. It's not metta. So it's this universal, universal metta is this wish for a feeling of friendliness or having a feeling of friendliness for all beings.
[57:14]
And it's, I think, better translated as goodwill. Goodwill toward all. Kind of a positive, welcoming, inclusive, warm, warm-hearted attitude, which I think Suzuki Roshi and Sojin Roshi the Dalai Lama all really embody, and you can probably think of other people that you know, teachers or people in your life who also make that a practice in their life, is this warm-heartedness. So what is this happiness? So in Pali, happiness is sukha, and I think more accurately it's bliss, ease, joy, And sukha is the opposite of dukkha. Dukkha is suffering and sukha is freedom from suffering or happiness, this ease or bliss or joy. So this is what we're wishing for people, that they be at ease, that they have joy, that they have this friendly feeling inside of them.
[58:27]
And the reason for this is because It's not just that you feel better, it's that sukha, this ease, this calm, this relaxation is related to shamatha, the calming practice, having your body, your nervous system be regulated, being able to sit stably. This is one of the five constituent factors for jhana and Zen. So this is one of the building blocks of our practice. actually. Who knew? Bliss and joy and ease are deeply supportive to our practice. And one of the things that goes in the opposite direction of that that's really a hindrance to happiness, to sukha, to this settled, grounded, more relaxed way of being
[59:29]
is restlessness and worry. And that's one of the five traditional hindrances. And restlessness is kind of the physical manifestation, the kind of body itching, and worry is the mental aspect. They often go together, but you may be more aware of one than the other. And when one or the other or both are present, it's very hard to settle. So this is one of the ways that we train to settle, to connect. And some people have a person, when they get around them, they just feel immediately more settled because they feel that sense of warmth and belonging and connection and trust. Or dogs. Or dogs. Or cats. Or cats. Or places in nature. You know, I walk outside and like, ah, the world opens up.
[60:35]
There could be many ways to do it, but this is one particular way of doing it. Sukha leaves one feeling well. You know, the worlds that you feel like, I had a good night's sleep actually. And one of the things that does is we have more capacity. This is one of the ways that you may experience having more capacity in your classroom so that things will walk with you a little easier. So this may all beings be happy. This is the happiness that we're wishing for them. Can you imagine what our world would be like if everyone kind of woke up in the morning feeling well rested and loved and a sense of belonging that we all felt like we belonged in and of the world? It'd be pretty great. I'd like that. That sounds pretty good.
[61:36]
So, you know, start with oneself, you know, because it does radiate. It really helps. Um, so this, you know, this, the emotional or sentimental love that may also be there, but it's not necessarily there. Sometimes, um, sometimes wanting someone can be hard. You know, it's a choice, it's a commitment, and sometimes commitments are not easy. Like you commit to do sushin, and sometimes it's just not easy, but you hang in there because your commitment and your deep love, there's a deeper meaning of love that isn't just about feeling good. It goes beneath that. But I want to tell a story about sarjan and metta. I also practice vipassana. And I sit with Gil Fonstal, who's also one of Sojun's disciples. And Gil had invited Sojun to teach a Papasno retreat together with him.
[62:39]
And I went to that retreat. And Sojun was so delightful. He was having a great time because it was all new in his first Papasno retreat. He was just like noticing everything. And in the Papasno community, they mostly teach netta through using phrases. For example, may I be happy, may I be at ease, may I be free from suffering, things like that, and just repeating phrases again and again, kind of like in Christian tradition, they do a prayer, you know, just repeat like a mantra. But Sojin did the instruction for metta practice, but he didn't teach it that way. It sounded a lot more like what he was talking about for meditation, which was zazen. And so somebody in the Kirin said, could you tell me where and how you practice metta? Because I don't understand. Do you do it during meditation? Because I thought when we sat and meditated, we were just supposed to focus on our breath.
[63:42]
And Sojin stopped and he thought, and it felt like he was reflecting on that particular question for the first time. And he said, oh, It's the only practice I ever do. Whatever I'm doing, whoever I'm talking to, I'm always practicing metta. I'm always feeling metta, radiating metta from right here. And he touched his hara. And he said, or you can say metta, or you can say love, or light. I like to say light. And I know that he did a whole series of teachings on light as awakening. So for Sosyan, there was no difference between this profound and endless wish for others' well-being and love and light. So this is just one place to begin to expand that practice to include everything.
[64:44]
So one We also, yeah, in the course of doing some research into the Pali Canon and these ancient teachings of Metta, which are like, they're all through it. I mean, we specifically, we chant the Metta Sutta, which is precisely about Metta, but there are references to Metta practice sprinkled throughout the Pali Canon in the Angathara Nikaya. There was this one that really intrigued us where the Buddha is talking specifically about how to practice with hate. You know, sometimes in Buddhism we talk about the qualities of mind having a far enemy and a near enemy. So the far enemy of love is hate. Duh. You know.
[65:53]
The opposite of love is hate. What did you say? The translation of the Dhammapada that you were quoting says, only through non-hate. Translation I like says, only through love. But you get the picture. That's the far enemy. The near enemy of metta is, I need you. I have to have this grasping quality of affection, which is clinging and pretty unwholesome. It can lead to codependency and all kinds of, yeah, not so great behaviors. But you might experience it as affection. For some people, that's how you experience love. So Joe's question is, it's a very important question. What are we talking about? So yeah, this is kind of,
[66:53]
important to unpack and to sit with and to, you know, investigate. Sire, play. Alex Sanaki, do you want to unmute and ask a question? Sure. I just sort of want to clarify a little bit, can I ask you guys to say a little bit about like active and passive? Because we're talking, the way you're talking about this as a practice, makes it sound like we're actively directing our mind in this, you know, way. So is that what we're kind of zeroing in on, is sort of an active directing your mind in a certain way? Or are we more allowing a naturally arising metta to come up? And how do we work between those two, the active and the passive side? Yeah, good. Thank you. I think we are definitely talking about active side, specifically.
[67:56]
I like to say Zen is a religion of action. I say that a lot. It's about what we do. This is about what we do. However, I would say the other comes along with it. My main goal tonight is to read this one Ayakema quote. Just kidding. I'm definitely going to get to Ayakema because she's got something to say here that really, really hit home for me and I think addresses what you're talking about, Kenpo. Can I ask a quick follow-up? Go ahead. Yes. I guess it's kind of a live question for me. in terms of if we're actively directing our mind towards metta, then how do we make sure that we're doing that while still kind of remaining somewhat natural?
[69:01]
I think I can find myself like jumping to metta. Does that make sense? Like, if I'm mad at someone, I'll jump to metta in a way that's almost like going against what I'm actually feeling in that moment. You notice that you're doing that? Yeah. Oh, cool. Great. No problem. Then I think that you could acknowledge that, oh, I have actually two feelings. I want to feel better for this person and I actually have more difficult feelings for them as well. Yeah. And you can just include that and You can let them both be there. You can want something terribly or not want something terribly and go on doing or practicing what you feel is actually the helpful or beneficial thing to do.
[70:03]
I can, you know, I can want three chocolate chip cookies terribly and I may have a crumb of one, but I know that three chocolate chip cookies are terrible for me. Both of these things can be true. And if I eat all three chocolate chip cookies, then I can forgive myself later. Thank you. Thank you, Genpo. I think Sue Osher has her hand up too. This is so great. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Wonderful class. I started making notes about homework, you know, action. will make notes briefly. I'm not good at homework, but gratitude practice is one way I can get into at least getting a few sentences of homework in, and then I can go do my usual distractive exercises. And when you get in the car and you're driving, do you prepare in advance so you'll access your loving kindness and not crazy driving?
[71:13]
Me personally, I think that's a great idea. Maybe I'll take that up. Yeah. But it sounded like you just were in that situation of terrible traffic and letting it go. Yes. Did you think about it in advance or did it just arise? No, it was arising in the moment. Yes. We practice so that we can do it more automatically when it comes up. Yeah, well, thank you for your talk and for your teaching. All right, cool. Kristen? I'm thinking about someone, a friend of mine, who is dealing with a lot of self-loathing. And... He's dying. And sometimes I feel at a loss around how to love him, how to support him.
[72:25]
And if love is wishing him well, I'm thinking about how sometimes I really want him to feel better. And actually, it's no longer a wish, it's a craving that I think can get in the way. And yeah, I guess without you guys knowing the particulars of this situation, I'm wondering if you have any guidance around the actual verb of love in this kind of context. So there's cultivating that intention, and then there's, what do I do with my speech and my body in order to love him? Or maybe it's more so a matter of just cultivating that intention and trusting that it will flow from me.
[73:35]
I don't know. Well, that's good. I definitely go with that one, Preston. Yeah. Please trust your practice. Yes. And it's, yeah, what you're describing is powerful. It's fierce practice, you know, under the most extreme conditions, right? Your friend is dying. It's a big deal. Yeah, maybe they have so much self-love that there's no in, right? I see you nodding your head a little bit. Yeah, where's the in? How do I get in there with this person? And you may not be able to. Linda and I did this Buddhist chaplaincy training many years ago. It was great. And one of the biggest takeaways from that was sometimes the best thing you can do is stay close and do nothing. Just stay close.
[74:37]
Let them know that you're there. And if you see the inn, because the universe might offer that to you, that's where our concentration practice that we do all the time, this zazen thing, it helps us with readiness. It helps us to open our prajna eye and say, oh, here's my opportunity, right here. Now is the time for turning word. Just now. That's so lovely when that happens. But you can't bank on that, obviously. In the meantime, you do what you can. And maybe that's nothing. But just being there. Being there. These emotional support animals, that's a big deal. The way they train them. And sometimes a really well-trained emotional support dog will alert to somebody they don't even know.
[75:44]
Oh, this person's feeling anxiety and they're just like... You know? It's so sweet. But they do. I want to be skillful like that. I want to be as skillful as one of those dogs. keeping over a little bit of material here in a minute. I think part of being skillful also is cultivating patience in yourself and through the other person and respecting that they are also their own person and they're also fully in charge of their own life. And just like parents have to learn to let go of their kids, and let them live their own life, and that's when you can actually really start having a relationship with your parents, is when they let you live your life the way you want to live it, and just accepting your friend exactly the way they are, even though it may not stop being hard for you, and it may not stop being hard for your friend, but you can hang in there with them.
[77:02]
I must. You all know who Ayakema was? A great Buddhist saint. She escaped the Holocaust in Germany as a girl. And she came to the United States and studied and eventually found herself in Sri Lanka studying Buddha Dharma. And she ordained as a bhikkhuni. She had a long life of teaching and helping others to find liberation on the Buddhist path. And she's the queen of metta practice. So if you want a nice guided meditation, go to YouTube. Look up Ayyakema, A-Y-Y-A-K-H-E-M-A. She's incredible. printed guided meditations or you can listen to or yeah, on YouTube.
[78:10]
There's tons of them. I want to read something that she said in a Dharma talk about love that really hit home for me. Actually, she says, love is something entirely different. Just like intelligence is a quality of the mind, so love is a quality of the heart. We don't just have intelligence when we have to solve a difficult mathematical equation. We don't just have intelligence when we have to make logical connections. The mind remains intelligent whether we do that or not. It's the same with love. The loving quality of the heart remains with us whether there's anybody in front of us that we can actually extend that love to or not. That quality of the heart needs to be cultivated. That quality of the heart needs to be cultivated. That is just a loving heart all the time. So this is, I think, addresses what Genpo was talking about.
[79:12]
It's not active all the time. You're not necessarily in a situation where you need to or feel inspired to extend loving kindness actively. But you're cultivating a loving heart all the time anyway. so that when the time comes, when it is necessary, you're there. You have this skill. You have this ability, this capacity. This is why we practice. So, yeah, thank you for letting me read that quote from Ayakima. And yeah, you can check her out. It's quite incredible. So I think we don't actually have time for breakout groups right now. So the reason to have breakout groups is for more people to get to say something and to hear what other people have to say.
[80:17]
But many of you have been raising your hands and sharing your questions. So maybe that's been done or will continue to be done. Yes, yes. So I do want to say a little bit about how you might explore metta practice going forward from tonight. So there are two main... I mean, there's many, many ways. As Mel said, you know, I'm just radiating metta or love from my hara all the time. My guess is that was kind of, in a way, after the fact. Like, he did many things, and then when someone said, metta, he kind of put them together. I said, oh, yeah, that's what my actual experience is. But I doubt that he kind of thought, I'm going to mediate metta and warmth from my heart. And yet, he was Suzuki Roshi's student. And Suzuki Roshi always talked about having warm-hearted practice. So I think he absorbed that. So I think that there are many, many ways to do it.
[81:21]
Some people are more mental and more verbal. Some people are very somatic. Some people are very visual. Whatever you choose to take up, find what works for you. Maybe you're drawing something. Maybe there's an image that really comes to life for you. And when you visualize it, that brings up that whole sense. Or maybe there's some words. When I do metta, I like to do phrases. And rather than doing like set ones, I find ones that really fit in the moment. Short. If you start by trying to figure it out, then it gets very heavy and you're trying to think of what's the right word or add more on. And it's just to keep it as simple as possible. May my friend be free of suffering. Whatever it is. Maybe feel well. Just simple, simple.
[82:22]
And as much as you can, pick something and be repetitious with it, just like Sazen, just like coming back to the breath again and again and again, and just see how that is. Because you may encounter resistance, and it may be too much resistance, but a lot of resistance is just like, okay, so there's resistance, and then it drops away and it changes. And it may feel superficial. Totally. At first. It may feel like, you know, this is even boring, you know, it's kind of repetitious, I'm just doing this over and over again, I'm saying these phrases over and over again. It has an effect, there's a cumulative effect, you know, in speaking of Buddhism being an open canon, you know, a lot of modern Buddhism includes neuroscience, what fires together, wires together, right? So, so, cultivate these wholesome states of mind and it gets easier.
[83:26]
You practice Metta over and over and over again and just get those wholesome neural pathways going and it gets easier. So I think it's really worth it. Yeah. And you can also do what's called a radiation practice. So there's phrases and there's a radiation practice. And I will send out a reading this week if you'd like to look at it. Certainly not required. But if you're moved, you can check it out. It's on both those kinds of practices. And radiation is exactly what Sojo was talking about. You know, I'm radiating metta from here. So particularly if you're a body person or you're aware of your body, you can just, you can feel that warmth and cultivate it. Because when our muscles and nervous system are relaxed, we feel well. We feel more open-hearted. It's literal.
[84:27]
We feel more open-hearted. We feel more subtle. We feel more connected. We feel more trusting. So look for the access points for you and see what you can turn up the warmth on. That's what strength the heat, but increase the warmth. You know, wherever it's blooming in your life, give it more. Start there, and then see where else you're moved to extend it to, having developed some warmth. Where would you like to share that in the world? Hax, I saw you had your hand up. It might have passed, but I was wondering about I guess what feels like a more neutral, like just accepting something versus extending meta to it. And I was just like a wondering, I was having an in it. And then I was wondering, well, maybe the more neutral thing is still meta.
[85:31]
It's just a milder, like to just start with being like, oh, it's okay that this is here. And I'm not really extending love and kindness to it, but That's called equanimity. In some cases, metta is used as a shorthand for all four of those, but they're also a way of saying that the fundamental attitude is this friendliness, and when it's meaning suffering, it's compassion, when it's meaning joy, it's medita, sympathetic joy, but also It's fundamentally not to pick and choose, not to want this or want that, but just to have this acceptance and letting go. So we'll go through all those flavors. Well, this has been amazing. It's great. Thank you very much. Really, really have enjoyed, especially the questions, the dialogue.
[86:39]
I love that, you know, like we say in our Shuso ceremony, let us call forth the Dharma together. So, thank you. Thank you, everyone, for bringing your way-seeking mind and calling forth the Dharma together. And thank you, too. And we're to a wheelchair. These impossible vows? Yes, these are possible vows. Beings are marvelous. Thank you.
[88:24]
Thank you.
[88:35]
@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_81.77